Otsego County, New YorkSaturday, November 21, 2026
Crime & Justice

Crime & Justice

Investigative reporting on law enforcement accountability, court proceedings, and public safety across Otsego County, New York.

Reporting by Dustin M. Lewandowski, Chief Correspondent

Investigation

Justice Denied: Otsego Sheriff Destroyed a Murder Case and Sabotaged a Tireless DA.

By Dustin M. Lewandowski, Chief Correspondent

September 30, 2026

Crime and justice reporting

On November 7, 2025, 71 year old Lynn B. Barton was killed by a bullet to the back of the head outside a building on County Route 49 in Morris. The man holding the weapon, David S. Hand, claimed he slipped on wet leaves while chasing a raccoon, testifying in court that he "accidentally discharged" his cocked pistol when he fell.

Share this story

All Stories

Analysis

When Accountability Fails: How Sheriff Devlin Uses Taxpayer Resources to Hide Departmental Failures

By Dustin M. Lewandowski, Chief Correspondent · October 5, 2026

Official statement from Sheriff Richard J. Devlin Jr. posted to the Otsego County Sheriff's Office Facebook page
Sheriff Devlin's official statement posted to the taxpayer-funded Sheriff's Office Facebook page.

Most people across Otsego County have no idea a tragic shooting happened right here in our backyard in Morris, New York, or that a quiet legal disaster just played out in court. What should have been an open and shut murder case completely fell apart — and the Sheriff's response has been anything but accountable.

Share this story

Endorsement

Minute Man Media Endorses Mike Stalter for Otsego County Sheriff

By Dustin M. Lewandowski, Chief Correspondent · October 5, 2026

Mike Stalter, candidate for Otsego County Sheriff, at a community meet-and-greet event
Mike Stalter at a recent community event. Stalter is challenging incumbent Sheriff Richard Devlin in the November 3 election.

Otsego County deserves a Sheriff's Office that leads with professionalism, transparency, and a genuine commitment to the communities it serves. After covering the failures of the current administration — most recently the botched investigation into the death of Lynn Barton — Minute Man Media is endorsing Mike Stalter for Otsego County Sheriff.

Share this story

Breaking News

Otsego County Sheriff's Deputy Arrested on Drug Charges — Accused of Smuggling Contraband Into County Jail

By Dustin M. Lewandowski, Chief Correspondent · October 5, 2026

A sworn deputy with the Otsego County Sheriff's Office has been arrested and charged in connection with smuggling controlled substances into the Otsego County Correctional Facility — the jail the Sheriff's Office is responsible for operating. The arrest marks one of the most serious internal corruption cases the department has faced in recent memory, and raises urgent questions about oversight and culture under Sheriff Richard Devlin's administration.

Share this story

Investigation

A Department in Disarray: The Pattern of Misconduct Inside the Otsego County Sheriff's Office

By Dustin M. Lewandowski, Chief Correspondent · October 5, 2026

The arrest of a Sheriff's deputy on drug smuggling charges is not an isolated incident. It is the latest entry in a growing public record of misconduct, poor judgment, and failed leadership inside the Otsego County Sheriff's Office — a department that has operated for years with minimal public scrutiny and even less accountability from the top.

Share this story

Court Record

By the Numbers: Tracking Arrests, Charges, and Disciplinary Actions Inside the Otsego County Sheriff's Office

By Dustin M. Lewandowski, Chief Correspondent · October 5, 2026

Minute Man Media is compiling a running public record of arrests, criminal charges, disciplinary actions, and civil complaints involving personnel of the Otsego County Sheriff's Office and Correctional Facility. This is a living document — updated as new information becomes available through court filings, public records requests, and community tips.

Share this story

Share this story

← Back to Front Page